Annuity123 is dedicated to providing Americans with unbiased information about retirement, answering the tough questions you want to know.

With hundreds of articles on every retirement planning topic you can think of, peace of mind is just a click away.

Who Should NOT Buy Annuities?

Stan The Annuity Man

Question: Annuities seem to be the hot financial product with all of the advisors I have recently met with.  They can’t be good for every single person, so who should not buy an annuity in your opinion? from Walt S. in Lincoln, Nebraska

Answer: Great question for the annuity buying public Walt.  Much appreciated for the opportunity to provide this much needed answer.

First of all, it’s important to know what annuities actually are and what they should solve for within your portfolio.  Annuities are contracts from life insurance companies that were originally designed to solve for lifetime income.  Since those humble and simple product beginnings, annuities have morphed into unnecessarily complex “trying to be” one size fit all dream products that can sometimes become fee monsters.

I use a simple acronym to determine if someone should consider an annuity.  Just because you might answer “yes” doesn’t necessarily mean that you need an annuity, but it could mean that it might be worth consideration.  That Stan The Annuity Man acronym is P.I.L.L.

P     stands for Principal Protection

     stands for Income for Life

    stands for Legacy

L     stands for Long Term Care

Notice that there isn’t a “G” for growth.  That’s because I feel that annuities should be owned solely for their contractual guarantees and not for potential market type growth.  You can do much better in the growth department with non-annuity products.  That’s a fact.

To make it even easier for you and the readers, I have listed below who SHOULD NOT buy an annuity in my opinion.  This list isn’t all encompassing, but it should cover most of the needed bases.  As with anything, there are exceptions to every rule, so these are broad stroke “should nots” when it comes to annuities. I’ve commented (giving my Stanalysis) on each to subside the annuity nitpickers.

You SHOULD NOT buy an annuity if………….

  • You are under the age of 40
    Stanalysis:  Most attached benefit income riders cannot be issued unless you are 40 years old.  If you are younger than 40, you should really have your money in the stock market for maximum growth potential, which means not an annuity.
  • You are looking for pure market growth
    Stanalysis:  Even the best no load, no surrender fee variable annuity is limited when it comes to investment choices.  Pure market growth potential is always found outside of the annuity world.
  • You are over 85
    Stanalysis:  There is an argument for people in their 80’s to buy Single Premium Immediate Annuities if they need income.  But that would be the only reason, period!
  • You are worried about hyperinflation
    Stanalysis:  There is not an annuity product on the planet that can address hyperinflation.  You can contractually add a cost of living adjustment rider (COLA) to a policy, but it will lessen your initial payout.
  • You need 100% liquidity & flexibility
    Stanalysis:  If you need full liquidity, then keep your funds in a money market at the bank.  No load, no surrender charge variable annuities provide 100% liquidity, but this is the only annuity type that could even be considered….and that’s a stretch.
  • You want all of the market upside with guarantees
    Stanalysis:  This is the typical variable annuity sales pitch.  The reality is that once you add guarantees to the annuity policy, then your investment choices are contractually limited.  You CAN’T have your cake and eat it too!
  • You want all of the market upside and no downside
    Stanalysis:  This is the typical indexed annuity (also hyped as “hybrid”) sales pitch.  Just remember that indexed annuities were designed to compete with bank CD returns, not the market.  Enough said.  No cake here either!

If you will just remember my Stan The Annuity Man saying of “own an annuity for what it WILL DO, not what it might do”, you should be in good shape.  Make the decision solely on the contractual guarantees of the policy, so if that guarantee solves for your specific goals, then an annuity purchase might be suitable and appropriate for your specific situation.  Don’t buy the dream, buy the annuity reality.

*If you have a question for Stan The Annuity Man, please send your question to stan@stantheannuityman.com.  He will answer all questions directly, and might include yours in his next Annuity123 “Ask Stan The Annuity Man” blog.

Click here to see more of Stan’s educational articles.

About the Author:

Stan The Annuity Man is a nationally recognized annuity expert and annuity critic, and has been called the national consumer advocate for annuities… and a walking middle finger of annuity truth.  He is a weekly RetireMentor columnist for The Wall Street Journal’s MarketWatch.com, and is the exclusive annuity contributor for About.com.  His highly acclaimed book, The Annuity Stanifesto, is a top seller in its category, and is known as the go to resource for all things annuity.

Stan The Annuity Man has clients nationwide, and is considered one of the top independent annuity agents in the country.  You can learn more at www.StanTheAnnuityMan.com.

 

Annuity123 does not offer insurance, investment, or tax advice.  You should always seek the guidance of qualified and licensed professionals concerning your personal insurance, investment, or tax matters.  Annuity123 is simply a platform allowing retirement planning professionals to help educate the community on various retirement planning topics.  Annuity123 does not directly support or take responsibility for ensuring the accuracy of the content displayed in the articles themselves or any feedback that may get added in the Comments section from the community.

2 Comments

  • Sid Peck says:

    annuities were fantastic when interest rates were 20 % … Better then the stock market .Sold a ton but not at todays rates UNLESS there are special concerns

    • Thanks for the post Sid. I remember the “Jimmy Carter rate years”, but I don’t remember 20% rates on fixed annuities. Must have been an interesting time. Take care, and I wish you the best. Stan The Annuity Man

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.